Nifty99000 100%

Sensex99000 100%

Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
Article rating: No rating
RSS

News

Firm on taxing agricultural income, Debroy says onus on states

Author: S Vijaykrishnan/Thursday, May 4, 2017/Categories: National

Firm on taxing agricultural income, Debroy says onus on states

New Delhi (IANS) - Undeterred by the raging row stoked by his comments,  NITI Aayog member Bibek Debroy is sticking to his guns that agricultural income should be taxed and says that the onus for this must be on the state governments. "I had said that agricultural income should be taxed above a threshold. I also said it's a state subject and it's up to the states to do it. That was my position then and that is my position now," Debroy told IANS in an interview maintaining that there was no contradiction between his views and those of Finance Minister Arun Jaitley.

His remarks on April 25 raised the hackles of political parties including the MPs of the ruling BJP who criticised Debroy's views saying such economists were not in touch with reality and did not know the problems of farmers.

The very next day, Jaitley stepped in to douse the fires by clarifying that the central government had no plans to impose any tax on agricultural income as it did not have the constitutional authority to do so. "The Finance Minister also said it is a state subject and the centre has no plans to tax agricultural income. How is it a contradiction to what I have said," Debroy wondered.
 
He added that even Chief Economic Adviser (CEA) Arvind Subramanian's remarks were in line with his statement.

Subramanian had on April 28 restoked the debate when he said that nothing prevented state governments from taxing agriculture income as the constitutional restriction was only on the central government. Debroy also said that agricultural income was already being taxed in seven to eight states, including Assam, Kerala, Maharashtra, Orissa, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal. He, however, added there may be cases where they taxed only "a certain kind" of agricultural income, "but they do tax it".

"Half the people who are creating this controversy don't even know that the issue of taxing agricultural income is being debated in India since 1953-54... People complaining about implementation don't even know there is a K.N. Raj committee report from 1972-73 called Taxation of Agricultural Wealth and Income, which talks about implementation issues."

"They don't know there was a Kelkar Task Force report in 2002 which estimated that if you use the existing threshold, 95 per cent of the farmers will be below it," Debroy said. The media was "unnecessarily trying to manufacture a controversy", he added.
 
The NITI Aayog member said that there were 307 individuals who declared agricultural income of more than Rs 1 crore ($156,000) during 2014-15, alluding but not saying so in as many words, that something wasn't right here. Debroy also noted there was also a company which had a profit of Rs 215 crore and yet claimed exemption worth hundreds of crores as its income was from agricultural sources.

"Now how is it reasonable to say that they should not pay taxes?" Last week after Debroy first made the remarks, NITI Aayog said in a statement that his suggestion to tax agricultural income was neither the view of the Aayog, nor it was part of the Draft Action Agenda document conceived by the planning body.

"NITI Aayog has already told you that my views are not the views of the action plan. Therefore, the action plan's views are not my views also," Debroy said.

Print Rate this article:
No rating

Number of views (187)/Comments (0)

S Vijaykrishnan
S Vijaykrishnan

S Vijaykrishnan

Other posts by S Vijaykrishnan
Contact author

Leave a comment

Name:
Email:
Comment:
Add comment

Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:
x

Videos

Ask the Finapolis.

I'm not a robot
 
Dharmendra Satpathy
Col. Sanjeev Govila (retd)
Hum Fauji Investments
 
The Finapolis' expert answers your queries on investments, taxation and personal finance. Want advice? Submit your Question above
Want to Invest
 
 

Categories

Disclaimer

The technical studies / analysis discussed here can be at odds with our fundamental views / analysis. The information and views presented in this report are prepared by Karvy Consultants Limited. The information contained herein is based on our analysis and upon sources that we consider reliable. We, however, do not vouch for the accuracy or the completeness thereof. This material is for personal information and we are not responsible for any loss incurred based upon it. The investments discussed or recommended in this report may not be suitable for all investors. Investors must make their own investment decisions based on their specific investment objectives and financial position and using such independent advice, as they believe necessary. While acting upon any information or analysis mentioned in this report, investors may please note that neither Karvy nor Karvy Consultants nor any person connected with any associate companies of Karvy accepts any liability arising from the use of this information and views mentioned in this document. The author, directors and other employees of Karvy and its affiliates may hold long or short positions in the above mentioned companies from time to time. Every employee of Karvy and its associate companies is required to disclose his/her individual stock holdings and details of trades, if any, that they undertake. The team rendering corporate analysis and investment recommendations are restricted in purchasing/selling of shares or other securities till such a time this recommendation has either been displayed or has been forwarded to clients of Karvy. All employees are further restricted to place orders only through Karvy Consultants Ltd. This report is intended for a restricted audience and we are not soliciting any action based on it. Neither the information nor any opinion expressed herein constitutes an offer or an invitation to make an offer, to buy or sell any securities, or any options, futures or other derivatives related to such securities.

Subscribe For Free

Get the e-paper free